Closing the Commerce Execution Gap: Retail’s 2026 Imperative

By Suzin Wold, Chief Marketing Officer, Rithum

Share post:

Peak commerce moments have a way of telling the truth. When demand spikes and pressure rises, the hidden cracks start to show—just as there is no room for error. Maybe it’s weak product data that turns into wasted clicks, or inventory mismatches that turn into disappointed customers. It used to be bad enough as a peak-season pressure test problem. But now it’s constant, because peak isn’t a season anymore.

Instead, commerce is moving toward an always-on peak “season,” with a steady cadence of surges, promos, trends, and channel shifts to meet changing buyer behavior. You used to have most of the year to prepare for big sale surges, to control when those surges happened, and how your buyers found you. Now, the moments can come from viral videos or surprising cultural shifts outside your control.

This isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but it is a big change. You can’t treat peak readiness as a project to revisit every year. It has to be the backbone under all you do. When you can’t predict every spike, you have to be able to adapt fast. Or you’ll pay for it quickly.

Scaling digital commerce is no longer about adding channels, but about orchestrating them with shared data and control.

High confidence, low accuracy

The Rithum 2026 commerce readiness index, which is based on a Wakefield Research survey of 200 retail and brand executives in the U.S. and U.K., puts numbers behind a simple reality: staying ready for an always-on peak season is nearly impossible when teams can’t trust what they’re seeing. Almost 75% of respondents to that survey said that data quality issues sometimes affect business decisions, and more than one third said it happened “often” or “all the time.” Meanwhile, 100% of retailers and 99% of brands say they feel confident measuring performance across marketing and commerce channels.

That gap between data quality and data confidence is the problem. Agility depends on signal quality. If the inputs are inconsistent, teams either hesitate and miss the moment, or move fast on the wrong information and pay for it.

The best fix for this gap is to focus on cleaning up three data sources of truth:

1. Product truth

2. Connectivity truth

3. Spending truth

One product truth across every channel

One of the best ways to adapt to always-on peak is to start with product truth and enforce it as a basic infrastructure. If shoppers click an ad and land on the wrong selection, trust collapses in seconds. If listings disagree across partners, returns rise and service teams absorb the damage. These are all product-feed fixable issues. Choose the product fields that cannot vary across priority channels and lock them down: titles, primary images, core attributes, and variant mapping. Run a daily check on your top promoted SKUs across your top partners and fix mismatches before you scale spend.

Stop running commerce at spreadsheet speed

When your product feed is reconciled, next attack manual work. Nearly half of retailers and brands say 26% to 50% of workflow still relies on spreadsheets, manual data entry, and manual approvals. Poor data quality impacts are felt across the org: 91% of retailers and 78% of brands call it a challenge. And data quality matters even more now because AI and automation scale whatever you feed them. Manual steps and messy data don’t just slow work; they multiply errors across channels.

Don’t try to transform everything at once. Pick one handoff that creates repeat errors or delays, such as catalog updates, inventory sync, order exceptions, or returns disposition. Replace one manual step with a rule based on current data so the same update lands everywhere it needs to land. Then move to the next handoff.

Put a reality gate in front of spend

In the last year, 91% of retail leaders and 84% of brands changed their marketing channel mix. Before you put paid support behind a SKU, confirm three basics: mapping is correct, inventory is real, and the delivery promise is one you can keep. If any one of those fails, pause spend until reality matches the message. Make the gate shared across marketing, ecommerce, and operations.

Then, stop scaling unprofitable demand. Know what an order costs to fulfill before you chase more of them. Margin leaks through channel fees, fulfillment choices, returns volume, and service contacts. Promotions can worsen the leak by shifting demand into the least profitable shipping option. External volatility adds pressure, too. In the survey, 46% of retailers and 59% of brands say they are at least somewhat concerned that tariff and trade policy uncertainty will disrupt sourcing strategies. When costs vary, you need to know which orders stay profitable. You cannot control that volatility, but you can prevent internal breakdowns from magnifying it.

Beware of how AI amplifies the inputs you give it

AI raises the stakes because it scales whatever you feed it. In the survey, 41% of retailers and 29% of brands already use AI based automation across areas like pricing, inventory, and marketing. Another 41% of retailers and 57% of brands have concrete plans and are preparing to implement soon.

You can’t fix bad data with more AI. Instead, go back to that infrastructure layer: get cleaner inputs such as product attributes, inventory signals, fees, shipping costs, and return rates. Standardize what true looks like for the data the system touches and block bad data before it reaches customers. When inputs fail, stop the automation. Do not let it keep spending, routing, or repricing using bad inputs.

Commerce will continue to be volatile. You can’t fix the market. But you can build in agility, so that no matter what comes, you can serve customers without breaking your promises. Close the execution gap by keeping product truth, data connectivity truth, and cost-to-serve truth aligned across channels. Then and only then will your growth hold up under pressure, because your fundamentals will be unbreakable.

spot_img
spot_img

Sign up for our newsletter

spot_img
spot_img
spot_img

LATEST INSIGHTS

CUT THROUGH THE HYPE
TRENDS